Chapter 10 – Religious Reformation: The Soka Gakkai and Nichiren Shoshu Part Ways

Nichiren Buddhism is a religion that exists to make people happy. It teaches the equity of all people and enables each person to shape their life with dignity. Since its founding, the Soka Gakkai has grounded itself in faith and practice based on the writings of Nichiren Daishonin, spreading Buddhism and working for the happiness of all people and the realization of peace throughout society and the world.

Today, the Soka Gakkai is widely known as an independent lay Buddhist movement. For several decades, however, the organization was a supporter and major benefactor of Nichiren Shoshu, a school with ordained priests that traces its lineage through the Daishonin’s direct disciple Nikko Shonin. Over the course of that history, the Nichiren Shoshu school came to deviate from the Daishonin’s spirit and teachings, falling into authoritarian and formalistic tendencies. This culminated in the priesthood insisting on the obedience of lay believers. In 1991, Nichiren Shoshu ultimately abandoned the Daishonin’s great wish for kosen-rufu—the priesthood took unilateral action to sever ties with the organization leading the advance of its fulfillment, the Soka Gakkai.

This chapter provides an overview of the history between the Soka Gakkai and Nichiren Shoshu, examining the true nature of the clergy as revealed through events in the 1970s and the 1990s, which came to be known as the first and second priesthood issues.

1. The Progression of the Priesthood Issues

Nikko Shonin inherited the spirit and practice of his mentor, Nichiren Daishonin, to realize kosen-rufu. To protect this spirit and pass it on to future generations, he relocated the center of his propagation efforts to the foot of Mount Fuji. A temple was established there that came to be called Taiseki-ji and later serve as the head temple of Nichiren Shoshu. However, over the centuries, Taiseki-ji’s clergy grew increasingly hollow and authoritarian, gradually losing the spirit passed down by the Daishonin and Nikko.

Tsunesaburo Makiguchi and Josei Toda, who took faith in the Daishonin’s teachings through Nichiren Shoshu, founded the Soka Kyoiku Gakkai (later renamed Soka Gakkai) in 1930 as a lay organization, launching a movement to revitalize Nichiren Buddhism in the modern age.

During World War II, Japan’s militarist government tightened its control of religious organizations, mandating the acceptance of the Shinto talisman. The Nichiren Shoshu clergy complied and ordered Makiguchi and Toda to do the same, but the two refused, determined to protect the integrity of Nichiren Buddhism. Fearing that associating with the Soka Kyoiku Gakkai leaders would lead to persecution, the Nichiren Shoshu clergy banned Makiguchi and Toda from Taiseki-ji. Not long after, both men were imprisoned by the authorities, and Makiguchi Sensei died in prison a martyr to his beliefs in the Daishonin’s teachings.

After the August 15, 1945, nationwide announcement of Japan’s unconditional surrender, the war ended, and the widespread support for the wartime militarist ideology crumbled. Toda Sensei was released from prison that year, and he began to reconstruct the organization as the Soka Gakkai. In the process, he returned to Taiseki-ji on his own accord, finding the head temple financially devastated due to postwar agricultural land reforms.1 Toda desired to work together with Nichiren Shoshu to advance kosen-rufu and relieve the suffering of his fellow citizens, and he decided that the Soka Gakkai would aid Taiseki-ji.

Starting in 1952, Toda Sensei initiated a regular pilgrimage program for Soka Gakkai members to visit Taiseki-ji, their entrance fees serving as financial donations to the head temple. Support for Nichiren Shoshu continued under Ikeda Sensei’s presidency as well, and the school came to enjoy both financial stability and prosperity. Over the years, the Soka Gakkai developed new facilities at Taiseki-ji and constructed more than 350 branch temples across Japan and overseas for Nichiren Shoshu.

At the same time, however, members encountered high-handed behavior and negligence from some among the clergy. Whenever this happened, Soka Gakkai representatives would approach the Nichiren Shoshu leadership to address each incident. Friction naturally arose between the two groups; the Soka Gakkai strove to fulfill the great vow for kosen-rufu whereas the Nichiren Shoshu priesthood placed emphasis on clerical authority. Amid this tension, however, the Soka Gakkai persisted in dialogue and efforts to maintain harmony.

1) The First Priesthood Issue (1970s)

With the establishment of the Soka Gakkai International (SGI) in 1975, the movement for kosen-rufu greatly expanded overseas.

In early 1977, Ikeda Sensei presented a lecture that expressed his views on the significance of the Soka Gakkai in the context of Buddhist history, observing that the organization could be said to fulfill the original functions of both clergy and laity, and he described Soka Gakkai facilities as modern-day temples. Some Nichiren Shoshu priests took these statements as a direct challenge to their authority. At this time, repeated incidents of anti-Soka Gakkai harassment by priests began occurring at local branch temples2 across Japan. This included open insults about President Ikeda at temple events and, at the funerals of Soka Gakkai members, desecrating the deceased in front of their mourning families. This series of incidents came to be known collectively as the first priesthood issue.

Behind it was a group who, in collusion with a faction of priests, planned to gain control3 of the Soka Gakkai by dividing the bonds between Ikeda Sensei, who was taking the lead for kosen-rufu, and the organization’s members. Hoping to protect the members from further attacks and restore harmony between the priesthood and laity, in April 1979, Sensei resigned from the presidency and became honorary president.

2) The Second Priesthood Issue (1990s)

In July 1979, Nikken Abe became Nichiren Shoshu’s high priest and chief administrator. During the first years of his tenure, Nikken did not yet have a foundation of support within the school, and he even faced opposition from other priests. To solidify his position, the high priest needed to garner support. In 1984, at Nikken’s strong request, Ikeda Sensei assumed the position as chief representative of Nichiren Shoshu’s Hokkeko Federation, the association of the school’s lay groups in Japan. In this role, Sensei continued to support the priesthood, even constructing and donating 200 temples over the coming decade.

However, by 1990, Nichiren Shoshu began to apply new pressure on the Soka Gakkai. The Nichiren Shoshu priesthood announced a drastic increase in fees for pilgrimages, including meals and lodging, and for religious services, such as the conferral of the Gohonzon. Then, under Nikken’s direction, the priesthood organized a plan to streamline their control of the Soka Gakkai’s membership and ultimately dismantle the organization by first stripping Ikeda Sensei of his standing within Nichiren Shoshu.

On December 27, 1990, Nichiren Shoshu made an abrupt announcement, dismissing Ikeda Sensei as chief lay representative following revisions to the Rules of Nichiren Shoshu.4 In response, the Soka Gakkai sought resolution through dialogue, to which the priesthood refused.

Then in November 1991, Nichiren Shoshu sent the Soka Gakkai headquarters a “Remonstrance to Disband.” But since the Soka Gakkai was an independent legal entity, it had no legal obligation to comply with the remonstrance. Three weeks later, on November 28, Nichiren Shoshu sent another document titled “Notice of Excommunication,” which unilaterally declared that the school no longer had any affiliation with the Soka Gakkai and all SGI organizations. This, in effect, called on members worldwide to withdraw from the Soka Gakkai and align themselves with Nichiren Shoshu and its priests.

However, the excommunication notice, which Nichiren Shoshu issued as a religious sanction, cited not a single passage from the Daishonin’s writings and included numerous factual inaccuracies; it was little more than a list of accusations unrelated to Buddhist teachings. In reality, it was Nichiren Shoshu that had separated itself from the Soka Gakkai—the organization advancing kosen-rufu—thereby straying further from the fundamental spirit of Nichiren Buddhism.

As a result, the excommunication functioned to enable the Soka Gakkai to achieve both official and substantive independence from Nichiren Shoshu, which had come to impede kosen-rufu. The Soka Gakkai now designates November 28 as its day of spiritual independence.

The series of events starting in 1990 is known as the second priesthood issue.

Nikken stepped down as high priest in December 2005, and he died in 2019. However, even today, Nichiren Shoshu maintains its deviations from the Daishonin’s teachings and authoritarian predisposition that formalized under Nikken. The Soka Gakkai therefore refers to the school as the “Nikken Sect.”

2. A Religion for Human Happiness

This section highlights key characteristics of Nichiren Daishonin’s philosophy, which affirms the infinite potential of every human being, and explores how the Soka Gakkai revived the Daishonin’s spirit for the modern age.

1) Buddhism for All People

Nichiren Daishonin states, “The Buddha surely considers anyone in this world who embraces the Lotus Sutra, whether lay man or woman, monk or nun, to be the lord of all living beings” (WND-1, 463). There is no discrimination in Buddhist practice, which includes that regarding gender or clerical and lay status. This is because anyone can equally bring forth the life state of a buddha by chanting Nam-myoho-renge-kyo.

Grounded in this fundamental Nichiren Buddhist principle, the Soka Gakkai, a lay organization, spreads the Daishonin’s teachings throughout the world, transcending differences in nationality, language, and culture. In this sense, the Soka Gakkai advances Nichiren Buddhism as a Buddhism for all people.

In contrast, Nichiren Shoshu fails to shed its insular and authoritarian culture. The school has asserted to the Soka Gakkai that their high priest should be revered and regarded in the same manner as Nichiren Daishonin himself—an assertion neither the Daishonin nor Nikko Shonin ever made. Such thinking reflects a deeply ingrained belief in the superiority of the clergy over lay people.

Yet the Daishonin writes, “Anyone who teaches others even a single phrase of the Lotus Sutra is the envoy of the Thus Come One, whether that person be priest or layman, nun or laywoman” (WND-1, 33). Nichiren Daishonin praised all who advance kosen-rufu equally as noble messengers of the Buddha. Discriminating against people based on status or rank has no place in Nichiren Buddhism.

2) “It is the Heart That Is Important”

When his disciple Shijo Kingo found himself struggling amid challenging circumstances, the Daishonin articulated an essential point for drawing forth the power of the Gohonzon: “It is the heart that is important. No matter how earnestly Nichiren prays for you, if you lack faith, it will be like trying to set fire to wet tinder. Spur yourself to muster the power of faith” (WND-1, 1000). He emphasizes that the key to revealing the life state of buddhahood is, above all, deep and unwavering faith in the Gohonzon and earnest prayer.

Elsewhere, the Daishonin states, “Even embracing the Lotus Sutra would be useless without the heritage of faith” (WND-1, 218). “Heritage” here is originally written with the Japanese word for “bloodline.” Just as a parent passes their bloodline on to their child, the “heritage of faith” refers to the transmission of the essence of Buddhism from mentor to disciple. Here the Daishonin indicates that the substance of this heritage is faith itself.

Today, Soka Gakkai members around the world strive in Buddhist practice based on faith in the Daishonin’s teachings, each person building a state of unwavering happiness in their own unique way while contributing to society in their respective roles. This demonstrates that the heritage of attaining buddhahood is not limited to a select few—it is open to all.

In contrast, Nichiren Shoshu claims the existence of a “mystic heritage” passed down exclusively from one high priest to the next—an assertion that functions to justify the absolute authority of the high priest and consolidate the priesthood’s control over lay practitioners. Lacking genuine efforts to advance kosen-rufu, Nichiren Shoshu relies on the authority of their priestly robes, promoting claims unrelated to “the heritage of faith” that the Daishonin emphasizes throughout his writings.

3) Many in Body, One in Mind: The Quintessence of Kosen-rufu

In his writings, the Daishonin urges his disciples to “make a great vow” (WND-1, 1003) and states “The ‘great vow’ refers to the propagation of the Lotus Sutra” (OTT, 82). To fulfill this great vow, he emphasizes the importance of the following point: “All disciples and lay supporters of Nichiren should chant Nam-myoho-renge-kyo with the spirit of many in body but one in mind, transcending all differences among themselves to become as inseparable as fish and the water in which they swim” (WND-1, 217).

Making the Daishonin’s spirit their own, Soka Gakkai members encourage and pray for one another while challenging themselves to share the Daishonin’s teachings and undergo the process of human revolution. This solidarity of mutual respect and cooperation reflects the model religious community that the Daishonin envisioned for fulfilling the great vow for kosen-rufu.

Buddhism describes the gravest offenses one can commit as the five cardinal sins.5 Among them is the offense of “causing disunity in the Buddhist Order.” Such actions obstruct the spread of Buddhism and deprive people of the opportunity to encounter teachings that enable them to become happy, ultimately amounting to the grave offense of casting people into suffering. Nichiren Shoshu’s attempts to undermine and destroy the Soka Gakkai—the organization advancing kosen-rufu—constitute this offense and directly oppose the Daishonin’s intent.

4) The Original Significance of Buddhist Ceremonies

Since separating with Nichiren Shoshu, the Soka Gakkai has established memorial services grounded in fundamental Buddhist principles. These services are conducted without priests, and they welcome family, friends and fellow members to gather and bid farewell to the deceased by offering prayers while reciting gongyo and chanting daimoku.

Regarding the significance of Buddhist funeral services, the Daishonin writes, “Now when Nichiren and his followers perform ceremonies for the deceased, reciting the Lotus Sutra and chanting Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, the ray of light from the daimoku reaches all the way to the hell of incessant suffering and makes it possible for them to attain buddhahood then and there” (OTT, 17).

What is essential in a funeral or memorial is not formalities or elaborate rituals, but the heartfelt prayers of loved ones for the deceased. In this sense, the Soka Gakkai’s services align with the Daishonin’s spirit.

Nichiren Shoshu, on the other hand, asserts that priest-led funeral officiation is essential for the deceased to attain buddhahood. This claim cannot be found in any of the Daishonin’s writings.

The Daishonin writes, “Because your beloved departed father chanted Nam-myoho-renge-kyo while he was alive, he was a person who attained Buddhahood in his present form” (WND-1, 1064). In this and similar passages, the Daishonin emphasizes that the attainment of buddhahood is a matter of a person’s faith and practice during their life.

Priest-led funeral officiation—and other Japanese funeral customs such as posthumous name bestowals and wooden offering tablets—were not established by the Daishonin, but became commonplace in later periods. Nichiren Shoshu, however, places strong emphasis on these traditions and requires offerings for each associated service.

5) The Dignity of Life and Respect for All People

The Lotus Sutra teaches that buddhahood exists equally within every individual, which emphasizes the universal principles of the dignity of life and respect for all people. For this reason, the Daishonin waged a tenacious struggle against teachings and discourses that sought to undermine the Lotus Sutra.

In his treatise, “On Establishing the Correct Teaching for the Peace of the Land,” the Daishonin urges Japan’s leaders, who sought to restore order in their tumultuous country, “Rather than offering up ten thousand prayers for remedy, it would be better simply to outlaw this one evil” (WND-1, 15). Here, “one evil,” refers to the ideologies and teachings that reject the Lotus Sutra’s philosophy that celebrates the infinite potential in human life. Throughout his life, the Daishonin fought against this “one evil.” By rejecting fundamental elements of the Lotus Sutra’s philosophy, Nichiren Shoshu ultimately constitutes “this one evil” in the modern age, from the perspective of Buddhist teachings.

Based on the Daishonin’s spirit, the Soka Gakkai champions dialogue, the power of words, to combat disparaging thinking and trends that undermine the principles of equity and respect for all people.

In September 1993, Ikeda Sensei delivered a lecture at Harvard University in which he addressed criteria for sharpening one’s eye to assess the role of religion:

“In an age marked by widespread religious revival, we need always to ask: Does religion make people stronger, or does it weaken them? Does it encourage what is good or what is evil in them? Are they made better and more wise—or less—by religion? These, I believe, are the criteria we must keep firmly in view.”6

Nichiren Buddhism is truly a religion for human beings—one that makes people stronger, wiser and brings out their inner goodness. The Soka Gakkai strives to put these teachings into practice in accord with Nichiren Daishonin’s spirit in the modern age.

  • *1For many years, Japanese Buddhist temples enjoyed a stable income acting as feudal landholders, leasing land for tenant farming. However, when the postwar General Headquarters of the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers (GHQ) directed the Japanese government to democratize farming communities, they were required to sell vast amounts of agricultural lands to tenant farmers, which brought financial hardship to many temples.
  • *2Before the Soka Gakkai constructed culture and community centers, members used donated Nichiren Shoshu temples for organizational activities, where they had regular contact with priests.
  • *3For more details, please refer to The New Human Revolution, vol. 30, Book I.
  • *4For the first time in its history, Nichiren Shoshu, set term limits for the leaders of the Hokkeko Federation—five years for the chief representative and three years for lay officers. In addition, a new clause was added to allow disciplinary action against those “who criticize, defame, or slander the chief administrator [namely, the high priest] in speech, writing, or by other means.” The revised rules, which immediately took effect, stipulated that “the status of all those heretofore holding leadership positions in the association is revoked.” This stripped Ikeda Sensei of his position as chief lay representative.
  • *5The five most serious offenses in Buddhism. It is said that those who commit any of the five cardinal sins invariably fall into the Avichi hell. They are (1) killing one’s father, (2) killing one’s mother, (3) killing an arhat, (4) injuring a buddha, and (5) causing disunity in the Buddhist Order.
  • *6Taken from https://www.daisakuikeda.org/sub/resources/works/lect/lect-04.html as of June 4, 2026.